A recent episode of TV’s Law & Order Special Victims Unit, specifically its 600th episode titled “Obedience,” set me off.  The long-running series (28 years) often takes its plots from actual crimes.  In the case of “Obedience,” the plot revolved around the rape of a nun by a Black assailant.  Stay tuned, I’m going to spoil the story to make my point. 

Mariska “Sandelli”
with Christopher Meloni

Anyone addicted to the Special Victims Unit (SVU) franchise knows that fictional Black criminals are few and far between.  The franchise has consistently understated the Black crime rate by portraying roughly 10% of its criminals as Black compared to about 30% in real-world FBI Uniform Crime Report arrest statistics.  True to form, the alleged rapist in “Obedience” was innocent but spent 30 years in Attica due to the bigotry of former SVU cop Elliot Sabler, played by actor Christopher Meloni.

SVU is headed by Captain Oliva Benson (played by actress Mariska Hargitay).  In the episode, she contacts Sabler, her former partner, and together they dig into the old case to find the real rapist.  That dirtbag turns out to be Father Anthony Lazzaro.  Worse, they find that Fr. Lazzaro also murdered another nun who was pregnant with his child and buried her under the church floor. The team finds the skeletal remains of the nun and fetus enabling them to link Lazzaro to the DNA of the fetus.

Of all the “heinous” (their favorite word) crimes I’ve watched on SVU, this had to be the most revolting.  And what actual crime inspired this plot?  The internet provided some actual cases of killer priests.

In 1913, Father Hans Schmidt murdered his pregnant girlfriend and dumped her dismembered parts into the Hudson River.  He was the only Catholic priest ever executed in the United States.  In 2006, Father Cesar Torres murdered his pregnant girlfriend in Mexico and dismembered her body.  In 2017, Father John Bernard Feit (probably ethnic German) was found guilty of murdering a female parishioner fifty-seven years earlier.

Mariska with Peter Scanavino
who plays ADA Carisi in SVU

I’m guessing that the scriptwriter of “Obedience,” Michele Fazekas (Hungarian surname), made a composite of these killer priests and decided a fictional Italian surname was appropriate.  Why?  Because she has done it before.

In 2020, Ms. Fazekas wrote an episode titled “Scorched Earth” (Season 13, Episode 1) concerning the rape of a hotel maid by a foreign diplomat.  The plot was clearly inspired by the actual arrest of Judeo-French banker—and international lech—Dominique Strauss-Kahn on charges of sexual assault of a hotel maid.  The Frenchman later admitted to a moral lapse and settled with the maid to avoid a trial. 

In the new and improved SVU episode, Strauss-Kahn was replaced with a fictitious Italian diplomat named “Roberto Distasio.”  On the show, the Italian was found guilty of unlawful imprisonment.  In short, a fictional Italian took the rap for a real Frenchman.

Mind you, Ms. Fazekas may have written the scripts but they were approved by Law & Order Creator/Executive Producer Dick Wolf (Jewish & Irish).  Moreover, the scripts are also passed along to the principal actors in SVU: Mariska Hargitay (half-Italian, father’s name Sandelli), Christopher Meloni (half-Italian), and Peter Muller Scanavino (one-quarter Italian).  Did they question Ms. Fazekas’s reason for using fictional Italian characters during the script readings? 

There is more than one disturbing pattern at work here.  The first is the very real ethnic defamation-through-fiction, a sin that was supposed to be in the distant past.  (Of course, “mafia” movies have been sinning for decades.)  But the larger pattern is the total indifference by actors who share our ethnicity to speak out for us while they vehemently defend every other group in the “rainbow.”  I don’t suppose objecting to a character’s name is penalized by Blacklisting in Hollywood.

The average audience for SVU is about 1.5 million viewers per episode with countless reruns.  “Father Anthony Lazzaro” will suffer syndication for eternity.  –JLM